This is a backgrounder Claude Opus created for me for articles above. I have not carefully factchecked it exdept what I quoted in the articles. DO NOT USE ANY DATA HERE WITHOUT CHECKING. Included as background you might find helpful. db
The East Coast grid PJM has seen a $50B increase in recent capacity charge auction. Opus that to the three other markets that run a comparable auction and the two large U.S. grids that don’t run one at all.
Important facts
Four RTOs run centralized capacity auctions: PJM Interconnection, ISO New England (ISO-NE), the Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO), and the New York Independent System Operator (NYISO). Each reports its clearing price in a different unit — PJM in dollars per megawatt-day, ISO-NE in dollars per kilowatt-month, MISO also per megawatt-day but split by season, NYISO in monthly spot prices. All figures below are converted to dollars per kilowatt-year for comparison. Capacity in each market is measured as UCAP or ICAP — installed capacity derated for the chance a plant doesn’t perform when called — and the derating method differs slightly by market, so these are directionally comparable, not identical down to the decimal.
PJM’s Base Residual Auction cleared at $18.25/kW-year (2022/23), $12.46 (2023/24), $10.56 (2024/25), $98.52 (2025/26), $120.15 (2026/27), and $121.71 (2027/28). The last two years cleared at the FERC-approved price cap across the entire footprint, with zero constrained locational deliverability areas in the most recent auction.
ISO-NE’s Forward Capacity Auction cleared at $38.76/kW-year (2024/25, midpoint of a $2.48-3.98/kW-month zonal range), $31.02 (2025/26), $30.84 (2026/27), and $42.96 (2027/28, one flat system-wide price). Because ISO-NE clears multiple zonal prices rather than one system-wide number, the first three figures are midpoints of a range, not a single cleared price the way PJM’s or ISO-NE’s own FCA18 result is.
MISO’s Planning Resource Auction, annualized, cleared at $7.67/kW-year for planning year 2024/25 and $79.21 for 2025/26. The most recent auction, for 2026/27, cleared in a $116-126/MW-day range across MISO’s ten zones ($42.34-45.99/kW-year), reported as a range rather than collapsed to one figure.
NYISO doesn’t clear one annual price; it runs monthly spot auctions plus seasonal strips. New York City averaged $152.52/kW-year in 2024 (from a $12.71/kW-month average spot clearing price); the rest of New York State averaged $24-72/kW-year over the same period. ERCOT (Texas) has no cleared capacity price: it’s an energy-only market, paying generators through energy prices plus an Operating Reserve Demand Curve price adder that activates when reserves run low, with a $5,000/MWh system-wide offer cap in emergency conditions. A 2023 Performance Credit Mechanism is expected to add a forward, capacity-adjacent payment once real-time co-optimization is implemented, but it isn’t reflected in a cleared price yet. CAISO’s Resource Adequacy program is bilateral contracting between utilities and generators, with a residual Competitive Solicitation Process auction only for capacity that isn’t contracted bilaterally; the one system-average figure available, a 2022 CPUC-reported $7,680/MW-month, converts to $92.16/kW-year.
What’s not yet cleared
ISO-NE’s 19th Forward Capacity Auction, originally scheduled for February 2025, has been delayed twice and is now expected in February 2028, folded into a planned shift to a prompt/seasonal capacity market with a new accreditation methodology. MISO’s 2026/27 result is the most recent, reported as a zonal range rather than a single figure. NYISO has no clean multi-year annualized series comparable to the other three markets; the New York City figure above is a single year. CAISO’s figure is three years old and comes from one secondary source citing the CPUC, not a current CAISO or Department of Market Monitoring report. ERCOT’s Performance Credit Mechanism has a target implementation tied to real-time co-optimization, anticipated but not yet live as of the most recent ERCOT materials reviewed.
Author and credits
This is a compiled dataset, not a single-author document. Figures come from PJM Interconnection’s own Base Residual Auction reports (2026/27 and 2027/28), ISO New England’s Forward Capacity Auction results filings and related FERC dockets, MISO’s Planning Resource Auction results postings (2024 and 2025), a Modo Energy research note on NYISO’s capacity market, ERCOT’s own Grid Insights materials on its energy-only market design, and a UC Berkeley Goldman School of Public Policy resource adequacy primer citing a 2022 CPUC-reported average. Compiled and converted to a common unit by Dave and Claude.
Link
PJM 2026/27 Base Residual Auction Report
PJM 2027/28 Base Residual Auction Report
ISO-NE Forward Capacity Auction history (Key Stats and Markets)
MISO 2025 Planning Resource Auction Results Posting (PY 2025/26)
MISO 2024 Planning Resource Auction Results Posting (PY 2024/25)
Modo Energy: NYISO capacity market and BESS revenues
ERCOT Grid Insights: Energy-Only Wholesale Market
UC Berkeley Goldman School: Resource Adequacy Primer
Summary
Converting every market to the same unit surfaces how differently these systems are structured, not just how differently they’re priced. PJM and MISO both clear one system-wide (or near system-wide) number through a single annual auction; ISO-NE clears several zonal prices in the same auction; NYISO clears dozens of prices a year across monthly and seasonal products; ERCOT and CAISO don’t clear a capacity price at all, by design. That means a single comparison table always understates some of this complexity — the PJM and MISO figures are the cleanest apples-to-apples comparison here, the ISO-NE figures are a reasonable approximation, and the NYISO, ERCOT, and CAISO entries are closer to representative snapshots than trend lines.
Within that limitation, the four-market comparison is straightforward: PJM’s 2024/25-to-2025/26 clearing price rose from $10.56 to $98.52/kW-year, and MISO’s rose from $7.67 to $79.21/kW-year over the same two auction cycles. ISO-NE’s fell over the same period, from $38.76 to $31.02/kW-year. No claim about why is made or implied here — this is what each auction cleared at, nothing more.
Conclusions
The PJM, MISO, and ISO-NE figures are primary-sourced, direct from each RTO’s own auction results, and hold up as a load-bearing comparison. The NYISO, ERCOT, and CAISO entries are weaker on the same standard: NYISO lacks a clean multi-year annualized series from a primary source, ERCOT’s Performance Credit Mechanism is a pending mechanism rather than a cleared price, and the CAISO figure is a single, three-year-old data point from a secondary source. None of that is resolved here; it’s flagged so it isn’t mistaken for the same kind of number as the other three.
edited and authored by Dave with close collaboration by Claude