Skip to content

Why AIEnergy started

AIEnergy started to correct the erroneous “Data centers are driving up electric rates” stories. AI was just an excuse for the companies involved to raise rates and use obsolete technologies. In very few places did AI raise overall demand more than 2 or 3% per year, less than renewables + batteries + demand response are able to serve. NYT & WSJ believed the hype.

Everyone in energy knows the tech is ready to handle the demand and actually lower prices, but the system is effed up. Good reporting in the energy press and from researchers makes that clear.

I learned from some very smart people and will write as long as I have something to contribute. I’m veteran tech reporter Dave Burstein (daveb@dslprime.com), and I love to hear from you. It’s a great service when you catch my mistakes.

Senate Energy Dems on Strong on Pollution, Data Centers, AI Safety. their opinions

Much more coming.

The three senior Democrats on Senate Energy and Natural Resources helped block a data center bill that passed the House 417-3. Martin Heinrich objected to the Ratepayer Protection Act on the floor, and neither he, Ron Wyden, nor Maria Cantwell voted to advance it. Heinrich’s argument, echoed by Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer: a standard that states merely “consider” has no teeth. On moratoriums, they also part ways with the House’s top energy Democrat. Heinrich and Cantwell have rejected one outright; Wyden has declined to endorse one.

They are the committee’s top three Democrats by seniority. Cantwell is also ranking member on Senate Commerce, which holds AI jurisdiction.

Martin Heinrich (N.M.), ranking member

Heinrich is the most technically fluent of the group on grid policy. His answer to the House bill is the GRID Savings Act, released August 3, 2026. He said it would give teeth to the voluntary Ratepayer Protection Pledge and called it a top priority if he became chair. It would direct FERC to write rules requiring large customers connecting to the grid to pay for necessary upgrades, while offering hyperscalers transmission service in exchange for voluntarily funding transmission-level upgrades. It covers users of 150 megawatts or more. His pitch is that big new loads should play by the rules that have applied to new power plants for two decades.

The FERC route is the real difference from the House bill, which runs through state utility commissions. It also reopens sticky federal-state jurisdiction questions.

On September 17, the day after the House vote, Sen. Jon Husted sought unanimous consent to clear the Ratepayer Protection Act. Heinrich objected: “Congress needs to pass real legislation with real teeth.” He added that data centers also need to engage communities, conserve water, and use clean energy and storage to limit air pollution. Sen. Bernie Moreno then blocked Heinrich’s bill. On September 30, cloture failed 57-43, with four Democrats voting yes: Hassan, Klobuchar, and both Georgia senators. Heinrich, Wyden, and Cantwell were not among them. The bill stays on the Senate calendar.

Heinrich and House ranking member Frank Pallone part company on moratoriums. Pallone backs one. Heinrich argues a moratorium pushes data centers to the places with the weakest rules and the least ability to push back: “we don’t want to race to the bottom.” He also says water will be a giant issue in New Mexico and nationally.

The item most worth watching is flexible interconnection. In an August interview with Heatmap, Heinrich described his Grid Connection and Congestion Management Act: generators that agree to curtail when the grid is full could connect and sell power whenever there’s headroom, an approach he said has worked in ERCOT. Grids are planned around the worst hour of the worst month, he noted, while vast stretches of the year have spare capacity. He also called interconnection queues an ideal job for machine learning, citing a FERC commissioner’s example of a 600-day study cut to 10 days. His bill addresses generators. Whether he’d apply the same logic to flexible large-load interconnection is an open question.

On renewables and costs, his rule for Democrats from the same interview: “you cannot create and manage the energy transition on the backs of consumers.” He argues that a gas-heavy buildout for data centers would push up gas prices for home heating, gas-fired power, and manufacturers. He has used permitting talks as leverage. In December 2025 he and Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse declared permitting reform dead after the administration halted five offshore wind farms under construction. In January he extended the pause until Interior lifted what Democrats call a “shadow ban” on solar. In March the two reopened negotiations.

On AI policy, Heinrich sat on Schumer’s AI working group. In May 2025 he said a 10-year state moratorium wasn’t appropriate when Congress hadn’t written guardrails of its own, and that preemption would have a better case after bipartisan federal legislation. He cosponsors Wyden’s Algorithmic Accountability Act.

Ron Wyden (Ore.)

Wyden comes at data centers as a tax writer and as a senator from a state where an influx of large data centers is driving electricity demand. He was asking who pays as early as November 2024, when he wrote Portland General Electric’s CEO after customer rates rose more than 40 percent in four years. He demanded documentation of load growth, a sector-by-sector breakdown of rate increases, and an accounting of federal subsidies. Oregon’s Citizens’ Utility Board read the letter as getting at data centers’ role in the increases. Wyden said he wanted to “blow the whistle.”

In November 2025 he joined Sens. Richard Blumenthal, Ed Markey, Chris Van Hollen, and Bernie Sanders in a letter to the Commerce Department and the White House science office saying Americans shouldn’t “bankroll Big Tech’s infrastructure” through power bills and water supplies. A month later, asked about green groups’ moratorium demand, he declined to endorse one yet, while saying taxpayer money had been significantly abused on data centers.

His distinctive 2026 move is about land. Responding to Trump’s July 2025 order opening federal sites to data centers, his bill would bar data center construction on National Forest System and Interior-managed land, with exclusions for specified tribal lands. Of Western public lands, he told Jefferson Public Radio: “These are our treasures.” Sen. Rand Paul blocked his unanimous consent request on September 30, arguing communities should decide.

On renewables, Wyden wrote the IRA’s technology-neutral clean electricity credits. During the 2025 reconciliation fight he said that if early projections held, the Senate version did almost 90 percent as much damage as the House bill. At an Energy Committee hearing in July 2025, he called Republican favors for “their Big Oil buddies at the consumers’ expense” a major reason bills are rising. He and Schumer then introduced the Lowering Electric Bills Act to restore the repealed credits, and he co-led a Congressional Review Act resolution against IRS guidance tightening the beginning-of-construction test for wind and solar, which the Senate rejected.

On AI, Wyden and Rep. Yvette Clarke reintroduced the Algorithmic Accountability Act in 2025. It would have the FTC require impact assessments of automated decision systems used in consequential decisions.

Maria Cantwell (Wash.)

Cantwell matters here mostly because of her other job. As Commerce ranking member, she is the senior Democrat on AI jurisdiction, and her record on data center energy is the thinnest we found among the three.

On preemption, she called the House’s 2025 state AI moratorium “probably too broad,” saying Congress must set national standards without blocking all state action. She then led the effort to strip it, first with Markey and then with Sen. Marsha Blackburn; the Senate removed it 99-1 on July 1, 2025. When Trump signed his December 2025 preemption order, she said its “overly broad preemption” threatened states with lawsuits and funding cuts for protecting residents from AI fraud, scams, and deepfakes. She isn’t against a federal standard. In March 2026 she signaled openness to negotiating one.

On October 7, 2026, she released a six-point AI safety framework, without bill text. It rests on NIST standards for frontier models, continuous government and third-party testing, independent audits, and incident reporting, including for unsafe recursive self-improvement. Her summary: advanced AI needs “clear safety standards, continuous testing, and reporting of serious failures.” It stands in contrast to the White House emphasis on voluntary standards.

On data centers, she rejected a moratorium early. When some 230 green groups demanded one in December 2025, she said they should push for an “above-all energy plan” that lets renewables meet future demand, and called the administration’s cuts to energy R&D and clean energy a big mistake. Beyond that and her cloture vote, we found no Cantwell statement on data center cost allocation. That’s notable for a senator from a state where the legislature punted a comprehensive data center bill this year. Her grid record runs through Bonneville: she led the push to expand BPA’s borrowing authority in the infrastructure law and applauded the agency’s 2024 plan for roughly $3 billion in transmission and substation projects.

The pattern

The senators are more procedural and more federal than their House counterparts. Heinrich wants FERC, not state commissions, to enforce cost allocation. Wyden wants data centers off federal land and wants to know who collected the subsidies. Cantwell is focused on model safety and preemption and treats data center power as a question renewables can answer. None has endorsed a moratorium. All three voted against advancing the House bill, which stalled at the hands of the Democrats most engaged on the issue. Husted’s spokesperson called their objection a cop-out. Heinrich’s reply is that the bill only tells states to consider acting.

The cross-chamber split is the one to watch. Pallone wants a moratorium; Heinrich says moratoriums send data centers to the communities least able to resist. If Democrats win a gavel in the next Congress, that disagreement becomes a negotiation.


Edited and authored by Dave with close collaboration by Claude